Signs of an economy in good shape?

Has the country economic situation improved?  Yes, at least going by the government’s decision to purchase four new Toyota land cruiser Prados as duty cars for cabinet ministers.

Four new land cruisers, each costing not less than Nu 3 million, have left Phuentsholing recently.  The luxurious and expensive vehicle spells social status in Bhutan.  Quite often, the type of car we drive is the yardstick by which we  judge our social standing.  The bigger the car, the higher you are on the social ladder, or so it is interpreted, unfortunately.

As cabinet ministers, and elected by the people, they are the highest ranked public officials.  They are entitled to drive Toyota Prados.  It was decided in Parliament.  With a generous quota system, members of parliament are also after one of the most expensive acquisitions in the country.

It is not so much about the highest paid public servants buying expensive cars, but about cost implications.  The government announced that they wouldn’t procure new vehicles until the economic situation improves.  With this decision, we can only surmise that the situation has improved.

It was also announced that the government would not buy vehicles for ‘pool vehicle’ unless a proper policy was put into place, including a strategy on procurement of vehicles by the government and cost implication for replacing and hiring of vehicles.  In the meantime, in 2014 alone, 167 new vehicles were purchased for the government and government-owned or linked corporations.

The then second pay commission recommended the government do away with the pool vehicle system in its entirety and create a corporate entity to manage these pool vehicles.   This was suggested as one of the many ideas to fund the salary revision.  Five months have passed, but we hear no more of any such policy.

The pool vehicle is an old issue.  Framing a policy without hampering service delivery and cutting misuse perhaps is becoming a challenge.  It has always been easier said than done.  To the credit of the government, they have done away with the Toyota Prados system to the wives of ministers, the Assembly Speaker and the Chief Justice, which was at the expense of the government.

Given the not-so-good economic situation, a lot of austerity measures were put in place after the government took over in 2013.  It generated some debate.  But many felt that unnecessary cost had to be curtailed.  One such measure was controlling chadi (preparations).

The home ministry was directed to revise the chadi protocol and the security measures for VVIPs and VIPs.  The prime minister, on his part, has slashed security personnel to cut cost, for instance.  While a new chadi protocol is up in the air, chadi is as elaborate as ever.

A variety of food items, dancers, pitching of tents and hoisting of flags at events have not decreased.  Arranging a makeshift stage for one night cost one ministry at least Nu 200,000.

The country has not recovered fully from the economic downturn, and everybody has to be frugal in spending the scarce resources at hand.  How well we do it is another question.

1 reply
  1. irfan
    irfan says:

    This news report on these vehicles by Kuensel feels rather incomplete. It only mentions Toyota Land Cruiser Prado model of base TX version to be registered as duty vehicles of some ministers and nothing more on the vehicles. But it’s one well desired model of SUV from Toyota all over. If I am not wrong, at a little less than 5 meters in length, it seats 7 to 8 people comfortably. With 2nd and 3rd row of seats extracted or folded, the loading bed is more than 2 meters. There is no end to the list of features loaded. The bottle holders at the doors can even hold 2.5 L bottles. Hopefully we are talking about the versions with either a 2.7 L inline 4cylinder petrol or that 3.0 L diesel with 25 percent green tax. When requirements are not for more than 200 HP, these are more than capable engines. It’s not only about the brand value of Toyota or the status value of this particular Land Cruiser Prado model, these are considered as more than capable off-road vehicles to be driven where there is just no roads. And as it has been mentioned here, these vehicles have become part the Bhutanese landscape to be honest. Our urban roads are always flooding with them.

    Moreover at around 3M Nu including the green tax, it feels like a steal of deal. In the other report it’s mentioned that with all taxes included, the price will be around 5.5M Nu. It doesn’t seem that Govt will be procuring them at 5.5M Nu. There are business policies in place. And this news on new govt vehicle import follows what has got our eyebrows raised a bit with ACC mentioning conflict of interest with two gifted electric vehicles in some of their report.

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply