Tourist and guide drown in Mebartsho

Accident: The body of the 26-year-old guide who jumped in the Mebartsho (lake), Bumthang to rescue a tourist who slipped and fell in the lake yesterday around 10.50 am is yet to be recovered as of yesterday evening.

According to police, the French tourist, 66, fell in the lake while taking photographs. Another tourists who had also jumped in the lake along with the guide to rescue the tourist managed to come out safely.

He also managed to pull the tourist after he was pushed ashore by the guide. However, they could not save the guide as he was washed away.

The tourist died a few minutes later from excess water inhalation. The tourist travelled as a part of 15-member group. The guide was from Bongo, Chukha.

Bumthang dzongkhag officials, police and DeSuup volunteers searched for the body until yesterday evening. Officials said the search would continue from 7am today.

This is the fifth incident of drowning at Mebartsho since April 2011. In 2013, an Indian couple died after they drowned in the lake.

Since 2013, safety of tourists visiting the Mebartsho has been highlighted in all forums and even discussed in the Bumthang Dzongkhag Tshogdu. The Tshogdu even considered disallowing unguided tourists at the lake but later resolved that the dzongkhag come up with appropriate safety measures instead.

It has been more than two years now but safety at the lake site still remains an issue as ever. None of the trails are secured by fence on either of side of lake. As of last year, the dzongkhag administration was still looking for funds to construct railings and traditional structures in eight hazardous areas to ensure visitors’ safety.

Dzongkhag engineer Yeshey Dorji said that the safety plans could not be implemented out of fear from disturbing the sanctity of the sacred lake. “We couldn’t execute the plans as the home ministry didn’t respond on whether the constructions should be carried out,” he said.

However, the dzongkhag had put up cautionary signboards barring visitors from crossing certain hazardous points.

Yeshey Dorji said that accidents occurred because the visitors go too close to the lake not adhering to the warnings.

Hotel Association of Bumthang’s chairman Pema Dawa said that save for the concrete railing towards the lake from the road point, no additional safety mechanisms were in place.

Pema Dawa said the hoteliers raised the issue in every meeting with local leaders, parliamentarians, Tourism Council of Bhutan and the Bhutan Chamber of Commerce and Industry. “The issue always got sidelined because of lack of budget,” he said.

Going by media reports, at least one tourist dies in Bhutan every year.  The causes of death are either altitude sickness or medical condition for most international or dollar paying tourists, while most of the regional tourists died from mishaps.

In 2013 four tourists deaths were recorded.  In May, a Swedish tourist died after she slipped and fell below Bumdra, located high above Taktsang monastery in Paro.  In October, an Indian couple drowned at Mebartsho followed by the death of an elderly Japanese tourist, who died of altitude sickness.

Records indicate that most international tourists, who died in the country, were elderly people.  On an average, about four international tourists are evacuated every year from the mountains while on treks due to altitude sickness.

Tempa Wangdi

2 replies
    MIGNIEN says:

    I add to my under comments that guides must know how to swim ; they can learn in the only swimming pool of Bhutan ; if the guides accompany tourist in water practises like drafting , or boat trip over the beautiful lakes in Bhutan , they have obviously to know how to swim !!

    MIGNIEN says:

    This miserable event lead a bad reputation to tourism Policy .
    We must distinguish two responsibles ; so , if mesures underneath are taken , this event will not still happen .

    A/ concerning the place

    1/ If the place is so sacred , why guides lead tourists on the place which is out of appropriate safety measures like rallings and fences .
    2/ Ridiculous popular beliefs block every safety mesures ; the engineer Yeshey Dorji said that “safety plans could not be implemented OUT OF FEAR FROM DISTURBING THE SANCTIFY OF SACRED LAKE”
    So , to avoid to distur the deities , the authorities prefer at least one death every year .
    3/ As long safety measures will not be applied , TCB must forbide the place to any tourist . Only monks can go there .
    4/ It wil be more comfortable for T.O. responsability to have guaranties that each old tourist about more than 60 years old has a doctor certificate which authorize him or her to make a trip at about an average level of 2400 Meters

    B/ Concerning the qualification of the guide
    1/ In France ,, according the law , every guide who organize out door trip or physical exercise must have a qualification called “first recue managment” given by Red Cross organization technicians .

    2/ If the guide would have this qualification , he could have taken first rescue measure of salvation .

    There is no point to crying ; it need to operate quickly saferty measures . Deities are out of duty in that problem . It a human responsability only !! Do not implore deities at every corner .
    A/ first keep off this old tourist by pumping his lungs with regular pressures with the hands opened , the body being face down , the had lightly down than the rest of the body .

    B/ When the mouth do not expurge water , turn the body on the back and give pressures hard and regular on the the chest ( hart area ) with the same rhythm than our own cardiac rhythm . It is necessaty to have near us a person able to go on when you are exhausted . And after a moment practice mouth to mouth ressuscitation a long time up to the lungs function by themselves .
    Envelope the body with blanket to avoid cold.

    Use only harm drinks WITHOUT ANY ALCOHOL gently up to the lips of the drowned .

    But as soon as possible , call emergency services . As soon they come , tell them what you have done and let them to go on . They know perfectly to rescue the patients .

    It is difficult to describe those action by words . The best is to have a course by red cross agents .

    It is time that TCB review the qualifications of the guides .

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply